Joined
·
101 Posts
Picked up my Denim Blue XC40 2022 Recharge Ultimate last weekend. So far it's been fantastic, one IHU reboot to fix Google Maps on the center console has been only issue. Coming off a 2019 XC60 T8 it's much, much more fun to drive. I had a lot of first world annoyances with the 2019 Senus system, and so far the Android Automotive OS seems to be a better long term direction. AAOS certainly boots faster than Senus and CarPlay.
My default music platform for the last few years has been Apple Music. I used to use Google Play Music when I had various Android devices, but I switched over to iOS a few years ago. I used Soundliz.com to transfer my library and it worked fine.
When I first heard about Volvo adopting Android, I thought that all of the apps available via Android Auto would be available. Alas, of course, it turns out that apps have to be specifically adapted to Android Automotive, and this in turn means a much smaller suite of available apps.
So, this week I wound up downloading and testing the following:
I was disappointed to find that all five services had no mechanism to download playlists directly to the car. All seemed to rely on the LTE radio to stream music. Living in the greater Seattle area I haven't had any significant issues with signal. That said, I would much rather download my music library to the car's SSD (perhaps in the background over an evening via WiFi) than rely exclusively on streaming.
One (very mild) annoyance - tapping on a playlist in every audio app gives you a list of tracks. There is no "play on shuffle" button, so the only way to play a shuffled playlist is to tap a track, make sure the shuffle is on, and then hit next track.
I've mostly been using Spotify, as it seems to work reasonably well. YouTube Music (on every platform) seems to have a very poor user experience, which is frustrating considering how much better Google Play Music worked on Android phones. The other three (iHeart, TIDAL, and Amazon) all seem to be just a bit less mature than the Spotify app. The one obvious difference is TIDAL's more expensive options for (theoretically) higher quality audio. Given that all of the music has to be streamed anyways, and I can't personally tell any difference between the audio quality, I'm not sure if TIDAL has a great pitch (ahem). TIDAL of all of the apps should make downloading in advance an option.
It appears that all of the audio streaming apps seem to be based on a common Google reference app, as they have very similar icons and features. I would be curious to know what the biggest roadblock is for audio apps supporting download in advance - is there no reference implementation in the Google AAOS base template app? Is Google not enabling it on AAOS for some reason?
For podcasts, I've been very happy using PocketCasts for years on Android and iOS devices. The AAOS version of PocketCasts app works great, with the same apparent issue as all the other audio apps regarding the inability to download podcasts in advance.
As a final comment, I'm surprised there is no Audible app. This is the only thing that "hurts" right now - the only way to stream an Audible book is via BlueTooth. Works fine, of course, but it's the biggest omission compared with, say, Senus and CarPlay.
At this point I'll likely cancel the trials for the other services and stick with Spotify. If anyone has any questions about any of the apps in the next few days let me know!
My default music platform for the last few years has been Apple Music. I used to use Google Play Music when I had various Android devices, but I switched over to iOS a few years ago. I used Soundliz.com to transfer my library and it worked fine.
When I first heard about Volvo adopting Android, I thought that all of the apps available via Android Auto would be available. Alas, of course, it turns out that apps have to be specifically adapted to Android Automotive, and this in turn means a much smaller suite of available apps.
So, this week I wound up downloading and testing the following:
- Spotify
- iHeartRadio
- TIDAL
- Amazon Prime Music
- YouTube Music (Premium)
I was disappointed to find that all five services had no mechanism to download playlists directly to the car. All seemed to rely on the LTE radio to stream music. Living in the greater Seattle area I haven't had any significant issues with signal. That said, I would much rather download my music library to the car's SSD (perhaps in the background over an evening via WiFi) than rely exclusively on streaming.
One (very mild) annoyance - tapping on a playlist in every audio app gives you a list of tracks. There is no "play on shuffle" button, so the only way to play a shuffled playlist is to tap a track, make sure the shuffle is on, and then hit next track.
I've mostly been using Spotify, as it seems to work reasonably well. YouTube Music (on every platform) seems to have a very poor user experience, which is frustrating considering how much better Google Play Music worked on Android phones. The other three (iHeart, TIDAL, and Amazon) all seem to be just a bit less mature than the Spotify app. The one obvious difference is TIDAL's more expensive options for (theoretically) higher quality audio. Given that all of the music has to be streamed anyways, and I can't personally tell any difference between the audio quality, I'm not sure if TIDAL has a great pitch (ahem). TIDAL of all of the apps should make downloading in advance an option.
It appears that all of the audio streaming apps seem to be based on a common Google reference app, as they have very similar icons and features. I would be curious to know what the biggest roadblock is for audio apps supporting download in advance - is there no reference implementation in the Google AAOS base template app? Is Google not enabling it on AAOS for some reason?
For podcasts, I've been very happy using PocketCasts for years on Android and iOS devices. The AAOS version of PocketCasts app works great, with the same apparent issue as all the other audio apps regarding the inability to download podcasts in advance.
As a final comment, I'm surprised there is no Audible app. This is the only thing that "hurts" right now - the only way to stream an Audible book is via BlueTooth. Works fine, of course, but it's the biggest omission compared with, say, Senus and CarPlay.
At this point I'll likely cancel the trials for the other services and stick with Spotify. If anyone has any questions about any of the apps in the next few days let me know!